E661: How much will sellers get from the FTC vs. Amazon lawsuit?
You probably know by now that the FTC has filed a lawsuit against Amazon, alleging that $20 billion was stolen advertising fees. But the question remains; what is the fallout going to be like for Amazon?
Thinking about taking some risk off the table? Or are you looking at taking an extended break from e-commerce in general? Know what your e-commerce business is worth with Quiet Light Brokerage.
In this episode, Dave looks at the potential for seller restitution, how much Amazon sellers could actually get from Amazon, and how sellers can maximize the chances of getting some kind of monetary compensation. Dave looks at past cases involving the FTC vs. tech companies, and Amazon's press release regarding this lawsuit to support today's topic.
In a rush? High-level timestamps can be found down below:
Timestamps
- 00:00 – FTC lawsuit overview
- 00:30 – What today’s episode will cover: comparable cases and settlement odds
- 01:20 – Tariff anxiety, business stress, and why some sellers consider exiting
- 02:18 – Why Dave recommends Quiet Light Brokerage for founders thinking about selling
- 04:13 – The FTC’s $20 billion allegation and why a settlement is more likely than a trial
- 05:12 – Why FTC cases often end in settlement: the historical success rate
- 06:09 – Amazon’s response and its biggest objection to the FTC narrative
- 07:34 – Amazon’s explanation for changing ad auction systems as it scaled
- 08:57 – Why sellers still care about auction mechanics, not just ROI
- 11:48 – Fleetcor Technologies Case: hidden fees, FTC action, and a $100 million restitution deal
- 14:45 – Why Amazon’s alleged $20 billion damages make a billion-dollar settlement plausible
- 15:43 – Amazon Prime cancellation lawsuit as the closest precedent
- 16:39 – The $2.5 billion Prime settlement and what individuals received back
- 17:37 – Why Amazon may care less about seller backlash than consumer backlash
- 19:02 – Why sellers should amplify the case and pressure Amazon publicly
- 20:59 – A rough payout model: what $20 billion could mean per seller
- 22:55 – Why calculating individual restitution will be messy
- 23:24 – Which ad products may have been hit hardest and a simple 8% refund idea
- 25:21 – The risk of Amazon burying the case versus forcing a meaningful payout
- 26:20 – How Amazon may need to change ad bidding transparency going forward
As always, if you have any questions or anything that you need help with, leave a comment down below if you're interested.
Don’t forget to leave us a review on iTunes if you enjoy our content.
Thanks for listening!
Until next time, happy selling!

